Dr. Andrea Middleton - Is It Bad For You? Approved by Dr. Andrea Middleton

Are Shirley Temples Bad For You?

Also Known As: Shirley Temple cocktail, Kiddie cocktail



Short answer

While an occasional Shirley Temple can be a festive non-alcoholic treat, it's usually high in sugar and artificial ingredients. Frequent consumption can lead to health issues like weight gain, type 2 diabetes, and heart disease, particularly concerning for children prone to obesity. Artificial additives may also pose risks. For a healthier twist, consider natural ingredient swaps like 100% pomegranate juice and sparkling water to lower sugar content.



Recommended Alternative

Long answer

Sugar Content and its Impact on Health in a Shirley Temple

The Shirley Temple, a popular non-alcoholic drink traditionally made with ginger ale, a splash of grenadine, and garnished with a maraschino cherry, is often associated with childhood memories and special occasions. However, it's also a beverage that can be high in sugar content, which can have various consequences on health. Here's an analysis of the sugar content in a typical Shirley Temple and its potential health impacts.

Understanding Sugar in a Shirley Temple:

  • A standard serving of a Shirley Temple can range from 8 to 12 ounces, and the sugar content can vary depending on the brand of ginger ale and grenadine used.
  • An average 8-ounce serving might contain between 20-25 grams of sugar, while a 12-ounce serving could have upwards of 30-40 grams.
  • The majority of this sugar comes from the grenadine syrup, which is a sweetened pomegranate-flavored concentrate, and commercial ginger ales, which are often high in added sugars.
  • Maraschino cherries also contribute a small amount of sugar, especially when additional syrup from the cherry container is used.

Recommended Daily Sugar Intake:

  • The American Heart Association recommends that men limit their intake of added sugars to no more than 36 grams per day and women to no more than 25 grams per day.
  • For children, the recommendations vary by age and caloric needs, but it is generally advised that they consume even less added sugar than adults.
  • Consuming a single Shirley Temple could meet or exceed the daily recommended limit of added sugar for many individuals.

Health Implications of High Sugar Intake:

  • Regular consumption of high-sugar beverages is linked to weight gain and an increased risk of obesity, due to their calorie density and low satiety factor.
  • Excessive sugar consumption can lead to insulin resistance, which is a precursor to type 2 diabetes.
  • There is also a well-documented association between sugary drinks and an increased risk of heart disease. Research such as that published in the Circulation journal indicates that even modest consumption of sugary beverages can lead to noticeable increases in heart disease risk factors.
  • High sugar intake has been linked to dental decay and cavities, especially in children who might consume Shirley Temples more frequently.
  • There can be a negative impact on mental health, with studies suggesting a correlation between high-sugar diets and symptoms of depression and anxiety, as per research in the journal Scientific Reports.

It's important to note that occasional consumption of a Shirley Temple is unlikely to cause significant health issues. However, regular intake - especially in children whose dietary patterns are still being established - can contribute to the development of unhealthy habits and potential long-term health risks associated with high sugar consumption.

Artificial Additives: Coloring and Flavoring Agents

Shirley Temples, the classic non-alcoholic drink traditionally made with ginger ale, a splash of grenadine, and garnished with a maraschino cherry, may hold a special place in our hearts and memories. However, it's worth examining what lies within—specifically, the artificial additives that give this beverage its signature appeal.

Most notably, grenadine syrup and maraschino cherries are the culprits containing artificial coloring and flavoring agents. Here's the breakdown of these components:

  • Artificial Colors: Commonly used dyes include Red 40 and Blue 1, found in many grenadine syrups and maraschino cherries. The concern with artificial colors, particularly in children, stems from research suggesting potential links to hyperactivity and attention disorders. While the FDA maintains that these additives are safe when consumed at levels found in foods, their use remains controversial. A meta-analysis published in the Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry (2004) found a small but significant effect of food coloring on hyperactive behavior in children.
  • Artificial Flavors: These are chemicals designed to mimic natural flavors. They're ubiquitous in food and beverage industries due to their cost-effectiveness and stability. However, the term "artificial flavors" can represent an undisclosed mixture of various chemicals, which sometimes raises questions about potential long-term health effects, although conclusive evidence is lacking.

It is also important to highlight that artificial coloring often serves no other purpose than aesthetic appeal, whereas natural alternatives exist, such as beet juice or fruit purees that can deliver similar colors without the added chemicals.

Nutrition experts often advocate for minimizing the intake of artificial additives. While an occasional Shirley Temple may not pose significant health risks, habitual consumption could contribute to an excessive intake of these chemicals, especially in children who are more susceptible to the negative effects. The Center for Science in the Public Interest recommends avoiding certain artificial colorings, including Red 40 and Blue 1, due to concerns about cancer risk and allergic reactions.

In conclusion, when indulging in a Shirley Temple, considering the type of grenadine syrup and cherries used—and opting for those with natural colorings and flavorings where available—could be a wiser choice for health-conscious consumers looking to enjoy this classic beverage.

Connection Between Sweet Beverages and Childhood Obesity

The role of sweet beverages, similar to Shirley Temples, in the context of childhood obesity is a complex and significant concern. Increases in obesity rates among children have been paralleled by higher consumption of sugar-sweetened drinks. These beverages, due to their high sugar content and low satiety, contribute to excessive calorie intake and suboptimal nutrition.

A study published in The Lancet indicated that for each additional 12-ounce soda children consumed each day, the odds of becoming obese increased by 60%. Shirley Temples, known for their sweet flavor, primarily derive that sweetness from sugary components like grenadine syrup, which is composed of high fructose corn syrup, water, citric acid, and preservatives. It's not just the obesity; these sugary syrups can lead to a host of other health issues, including type 2 diabetes and metabolic syndrome in younger populations.

It's essential to consider the typical ingredients in a Shirley Temple:

  • Grenadine (1 ounce contains approximately 3-4 teaspoons of sugar)
  • Ginger ale or lemon-lime soda (8 ounces contain about 7 teaspoons of sugar)
  • Maraschino cherry (1 cherry contains nearly 1 teaspoon of sugar)

Combining these ingredients can result in a beverage with sugar content rivaling that of the average soda. This is concerning given the American Heart Association's recommendation that children consume no more than 3-4 teaspoons of added sugars per day. One Shirley Temple could potentially exceed a child's daily sugar limit.

Furthermore, consistent exposure to sweet tastes may reinforce preferences for sugary foods and drinks, making it harder for children to accept less sugary or more healthful options like water, whole fruits, and vegetables. This preference can degrade dietary habits throughout their lives.

Preventative measures by healthcare providers and public health organizations stress the reduction of sugary drink intake among children. For example, the World Health Organization has recommended that intake of free sugars be reduced to less than 10% of total energy intake, with a further reduction to below 5% for additional benefits.

While an occasional Shirley Temple may not directly cause obesity, habitual consumption can significantly contribute to excessive caloric intake, poor nutrition, and an increased risk of childhood obesity and related diseases. It's the pattern of consumption that draws concern, and it's worth noting that the environment in which children are raised can influence their eating and drinking habits extensively.

Parents and caregivers should be aware of the amount of sugar present in Shirley Temples and consider them an occasional treat rather than a regular part of a child's diet. Offering children healthier alternatives and creating an environment where sugary drinks are the exception, not the rule, can play a pivotal role in combating the childhood obesity epidemic.

Alternatives to the Classic Shirley Temple Recipe

The classic Shirley Temple, a non-alcoholic mixed drink traditionally made with ginger ale, a splash of grenadine, and garnished with a maraschino cherry, is a favorite among many, particularly as a nostalgic childhood beverage. However, concerns over the sugar content and artificial ingredients in traditional grenadine and maraschino cherries may prompt health-conscious individuals to seek healthier alternatives.

Making a healthier Shirley Temple involves swapping out high-sugar ingredients for more natural and lower-calorie options. Here are a few modifications one can make to enjoy this beverage without the guilt:

  • Use 100% Pomegranate Juice: To cut down on the processed sugars found in grenadine, opt for 100% pomegranate juice which provides natural sweetness and offers antioxidants without added sugars or artificial colors.
  • Choose A Healthier Fizz: Instead of traditional ginger ale, which can be high in added sugars, consider using sparkling water with a splash of natural ginger juice or ginger tea to give that needed fizz and flavor without the extra sugar.
  • Natural Sweeteners: Individuals desiring a sweeter taste might add a teaspoon of raw honey or pure maple syrup, which are natural sweeteners and may have a lower glycemic index than refined sugar.
  • Fresh Fruit Garnish: Rather than topping the drink with a maraschino cherry that typically contains artificial colors and flavors, opt for fresh cherries or pomegranate arils that present the benefits of fiber, vitamins, and natural sweetness.
  • Herbal Infusions: Infusing the sparkling water with fresh mint or basil can add a refreshing twist and complexity to the flavor profile without any added sugar or calories.

Each of these modifications not only reduces the sugar intake but also introduces more nutrients to the beverage, making it a healthier choice. Furthermore, these suggestions increase the aesthetic appeal of the drink with natural colors and textures, elevating the overall drinking experience.

It is important to note that while moderate consumption of a classic Shirley Temple is not inherently 'bad' for you, being mindful of the sugar and artificial ingredient content can help manage one's daily intake, contributing to a more balanced diet. For consumers who enjoy Shirley Temples frequently, these alternatives offer the opportunity to indulge in a familiar taste with a healthier approach.

For those watching their sugar intake, diabetic-friendly sweeteners like stevia or erythritol can also be considered, although it's always important to check for personal tolerance as non-nutritive sweeteners can cause digestive discomfort for some individuals. The key to modifying the classic Shirley Temple is to prioritize natural ingredients and be mindful of overall sugar consumption within the context of one's entire diet.

Empathy for personal taste preferences is paramount, and it's encouraged to experiment with different variations to craft a version of the Shirley Temple that aligns with individual health goals and palate preferences.

Frequently asked questions

Regular consumption of Shirley Temples, which are high in sugar and often contain artificial additives, can contribute to an increased risk of childhood obesity, type 2 diabetes, and may influence poor dietary habits. It's advisable to view Shirley Temples as an occasional treat and not a regular part of a child's diet.

If you're watching your sugar intake, making a Shirley Temple with sugar-free alternatives like stevia or erythritol, and choosing natural ingredients can help keep your sugar consumption in check. However, always monitor your body's response to non-nutritive sweeteners as they can cause digestive discomfort in some individuals.

For a Shirley Temple with no artificial colors and flavors, select natural grenadine alternatives like pomegranate juice, opt for sparkling water instead of sugary ginger ale, and garnish with fresh fruit like pomegranate arils or cherries rather than maraschino cherries.

Yes, using 100% pomegranate juice is a great alternative to grenadine if you're looking to reduce processed sugars. Pomegranate juice offers natural sweetness with the added benefit of antioxidants, without added sugars or artificial colors.

Ask a question about Shirley Temples and our team will publish the answer as soon as possible.

Possible short-term side effects

  • increased blood sugar
  • insulin spike
  • possible hyperactivity in children
  • dental decay
  • sugar crash
  • potential allergic reaction to artificial colors

Possible long-term side effects

  • weight gain
  • obesity
  • type 2 diabetes
  • heart disease
  • insulin resistance
  • dental problems
  • worsened mental health symptoms

Ingredients to be aware of

Healthier alternatives

  • 100% pomegranate juice
  • sparkling water
  • natural ginger juice or ginger tea
  • raw honey or pure maple syrup
  • fresh cherries or pomegranate arils
  • herbal infusions
  • stevia or erythritol for diabetics

Our Wellness Pick (what is this?)

Zevia Ginger Ale

  • Zero-calorie refreshment
  • No artificial sweeteners
  • Caffeine-free
  • Non-GMO Project Verified
  • Gluten-free & Vegan
Learn More!

Thank you for your feedback!

Written by Diane Saleem
Published on: 03-18-2024

Thank you for your feedback!

Written by Diane Saleem
Published on: 03-18-2024

Random Page

Check These Out!